What is the Healthiest Peanut Butter?

October 29, 2016   42 Comments

What is the Healthiest Peanut Butter? It should be easy to find the healthiest peanut butter but it isn’t.

What is the Healthiest Peanut Butter

The world of food marketing makes it so much harder than it should be to determine what the best choice. Peanut butter is one of those foods that is incredibly nutritious and can be an excellent choice for healthy eating.

A form of peanut butter is the food that the United Nations uses to feed the malnourished in famine situation because it has fat, carbohydrates, proteins and it is an excellent source of vitamin E and B vitamins. If you like it – you should eat it!

I first talked about peanut butter years ago when my husband came back with Jiffy from Walmart. He thought all peanut butter was the same – simply roasted peanuts. PB2 is also a favorite of mine because it adds peanut butter flavor without the calories.

I went to Target to see if I could pick out the healthiest and least expensive peanut butter option to feed my family.

First up – Skippy – Natural. I knew that regular Skippy wouldn’t be the best choice because of the added sugar and palm oil – but, guess what? Natural Skippy has palm oil and sugar, too! I don’t think there is much of a difference between “natural” and regular Skippy. It is too bad because this was the cheapest of all the peanut butters.

Then, I checked out a much more expensive brand (twice the price!) – Justin’s. The packaging is so cute! But, alas, Justin’s also added palm oil to its peanut butter (but no sugar). This made me sad because I wanted it to be perfect.

Teddie Peanut Butter is a regional brand to Massachusetts. You will find regional brands throughout the USA that ARE what you are looking for. This is an excellent choice with simply peanuts and salt in the ingredients list. It was about 30% more than Skippy’s Natural.

Finally, the Target brand – Simply Balanced Organic Creamy Peanut Butter – was the best because it was simply “organic roasted peanuts”. It cost twice as much as Skippy.

I don’t think it is necessary to eat organic peanut butter for it to be healthy. I do think that added sugar and palm oil are not necessary or good for you.

Plenty of other great choices are out there. The Trader Joe’s brand is excellent, Smucker’s has an all natural choice (which is only roasted peanuts and salt), and you can’t miss at Whole Foods (where they don’t sell Skippy or Jif).

What is your favorite peanut butter? Why do you like it?

Other posts you might like:


How To Choose Healthy Peanut Butter

Peanut butter is a great addition to a healthy snack. Spreading it on apples or crackers is an excellent way to add fat and protein (and taste!) to a dull food....


Peanut Butter Lovers: A 45 Calorie Solution That Will Save Your Waistline

Snack Girl features peanut butter A LOT. I happen to love the stuff and I use it almost every day....

Get Free Email Updates! Yes please!


Wegmans makes a peanut butter that is just peanuts and it is a lot cheaper than healthy name brands.

on October 29, 2016

I usually buy Kirkland (Canada) all natural PB from Costco. Excellent taste and good price. I also have purchased a brand in the US called Richards. It was very good too. Both were 100% peanuts only.

on October 29, 2016

I've only bought Teddie for two years now. That's usually breakfast and lunch for my kids, so I get 3-6 jars a month from Amazon home delivery:)

on October 29, 2016

ITeddie also offers a "no salt" version, so if you don't want added salt, you can get that one (and this is probably true for other regional natural brands). I wonder why the national-brand "ordinary" peanut butters add extra oil? I guess it probably has to do with achieving a certain consistency? Palm oil is used in cooking in lots of parts of the world, but the way oil palms are raised is super bad for the environment. Cottonseed oil I've heard lots of bad things about (mainly revolving around the notion that it's got more pesticides in it because cotton is a non-food crop), but it seems that probably it's as safe as any mass-produced oil.

on October 29, 2016

I live in Eastern North Carolina and here we have Bertie County Peanuts. They sell a peanut butter that is just peanuts, nothing else! I have tried many different kinds of natural peanut butter and this is by far the absolute best! It can be ordered online from their website,

on October 29, 2016

I thought it was very important to buy organic peanut butter as I read the peanuts sit for long periods and to prevent mold they are sprayed with pesticides and such.

on October 29, 2016

Kroger brand All Natural. Peanuts. Salt. I can get it for $1 on sale. Yes...I said $1!!

on October 29, 2016

I've started grinding my own in the bulk food section of my grocery store.They have peanuts and almonds.Delicious!

on October 29, 2016

I forgot! I also buy the Costco Organic peanut butter - just roasted peanuts and salt. Love it!

on October 29, 2016

Since this allergy stuff was absent all of my life I concluded long before it was popular that organic is the way to go for the food I consume the most and leave the non-organic food to that which I only consume occasionally or rarely. Not just allergies but hordes of health conditions have been suspect in US food production practices. I've read about our food for 50 years. I'm no scientist, I can't refer to scientific papers but my own sense tells me to err on the side of caution like most every other industrialized country has done. So I choose organic peanut butter with only salt and keep it refrigerated. The word ''natural'' has no legal meaning, its a marketing word.…

on October 29, 2016

I'm surprised you didn't mention Adam's. It's affordable and perfect. We get the unsalted, so it's just peanuts on the ingredients list. Maybe it's a West coast thing.

on October 29, 2016

Jif Brand Because It Does Not Contain Cottonseed Oil.

on October 29, 2016

I grind peanuts at whole foods no added salt or sugar

no oil.

on October 29, 2016

I make mine in WINCO's bulk sections... it's just peanuts I also make almond butter.

on October 29, 2016

I actually prefer almond butter for the consistency but get that or peanut butter from Kroger's organic aisle. The Simple Truth brand is great - I get unsalted and add my own salt if I want it so that I have control over the amount.

on October 29, 2016

I always buy the store brand at Price Rite but after reading all this I may start just purchasing peanuts and grinding my own at home in the new food processor I won from doing surveys.

I saw where people said they grind their peanuts at the store. Is this actually safe? Do we know how often the equipment is cleaned so mold etc. does not get into the batch you are grinding? Just wondering.

on October 29, 2016

I have been making my own peanut butter for years because of the sugar and oil added. I just buy a couple jars of unsalted, dry roasted peanuts (I like the dry roasted because they are not as oily) and put them in my food processor and mix to a creamy consistency. So easy and a jar of peanuts you can buy for less than $3. I also have used a Vita Mixer but find it easier in the food processor but both will do the job.

on October 29, 2016

I like Better'n peanut butter--I don't think it would pass your test but I like it better than PB 2.

on October 29, 2016

I buy Kraft All Natural (crunchy).

It seems it is the only supermarket brand that I can find that is only made with peanuts.

No salt, no sugar, no palm oil, no preservatives.

on October 29, 2016

i started noticing the palm oil addition about a year ago to most pb on the shelf. its what they have replaced trans fats with.

its in a lot of stuff, i don't want it. you have to really read the labels. i had bought a bogo pb deal and now im stuck with 2 giant jars. i figure ill make pb cookies and take them to parties where people arent watching what they eat.

on October 29, 2016

Nancy, I use cheap PB [skippy] for my chipmunks, squirrels & woodpeckers to add seed to and spread on stale bread, crackers, etc. I leave it on a big rock under my feeder with a rock shelter made by leaning rocks together. Its so cute and entertaining.

on October 29, 2016

We use both creamy and crunchy versions of "Crazy Richard's". They are both delicious and the only ingredient is peanuts. The only disadvantage is that you have to stir the peanut oil back into the nuts before spreading... but the taste is wonderful!

on October 29, 2016

Sheila, I find that if you refrigerate the type of PB that requires stirring it only has to be stirred once, when you first open it. And I also read that refrigeration slows down aflatoxin, a natural-occurring nasty, from growing.

on October 29, 2016

Crazy Richard's all natural from Lucky's Market. 100% peanuts and BPA free.

on October 30, 2016

I was buying Crazy Richards - it only contained peanuts and peanut oil - no salt or sugar. Am looking for a new brand.

on October 31, 2016

I believe that in order to be legally called peanut butter, according to the US government, it has to include added oil. I believe I even read somewhere that the oil has to be partially or fully hydrogenated. Notice the Skippy is called 'peanut butter spread.'

on October 31, 2016

Smucker's Natural Creamy is one of my all time favorite Peanut Butters. Just peanuts & salt! It's so good!

on November 2, 2016

Smucker's Natural peanut butter is one of my all time favorite peanut butters....just peanuts and salt! It is So good!

on November 2, 2016

Our family really loves Old Home All-Natural refrigerated Peanut Butter (Non-GMO), .95 peanuts & .05 sea salt. Found at Super Target in their refrigerated section. Creamy, Crunchy, Honey Creamy, and Honey Crunchy. Thank you for your great snack ideas!

on November 27, 2016

Yeah, this is a good butter, I always make a breakfast for the kids with this butter. Sometimes I even eat it by myself.

on December 17, 2016

I like to eat Jif is that ok to eat

on January 26, 2017

True confessions...JIF. Although the from time to time I try the all natural and the peanut only brands, but for consistency of flavor and texture ,I keep going back to Jif. Two teaspoons a day will not kill far as I know. The two teaspoons are usually on an apple or on oatmeal toast.

on February 1, 2017

Snack girl! Just found your site! Beware: WHOLE FOODS brand of peanut butter has palm oil! Gross. Just shows you have to read labels!

on March 30, 2017

I live in Canada and I like Kraft All Natural crunchy peanut butter which contains 100% peanuts and/or PC Blue Menu Just Peanuts Peanut Butter - Crunchy which like Kraft is 100% peanuts. I will buy either, whichever is cheaper that week.

on April 6, 2017

I bought Kreme which has been bought by Crazy Richards. I don' need added salt so 100% peanuts is great. However, not finding it locally has had me try Whole Foods and Trader Joes, which are extremely inferior. I want a rich roasted flavor and lots and lots of peanuts in my crunchy peanut butter, neither of which WF or TJ have. One can't get away from the sugar as all nuts contain sugar. But added sugar? Sugar is a killer. Wake up people!

on September 4, 2017

As to cottonseed in oil. It’s not pesticides because the boleweavel is basically extinct, but defoliation herbicides aka agent orange that gets you!

on April 30, 2018

The plastic containers they come in are of a concern, as well. Smuckers organic creamy has the added salt, no palm oil, but are in glass jars.

on August 25, 2020

I buy Kraft ONLY PEANUTS. You can get it salted with sea salt or not. I live in Canada.

on August 25, 2020


on August 25, 2020

I discovered a peanut butter brand some time ago when looking for pure peanut butter to make bird seed cakes with. It is "Crazy Richard's 100% peanuts". That is all that is in it. Has to be stirred and can be kept on pantry shelf. Pretty good peanut butter. Found it at my WalMart at the time, but I see they have it on Amazon. A little pricey.

on August 25, 2020

I buy Peanut butter with Flax and chia seeds from Aldi

when it's available, which is not very often. It does contain some palm oil, but this is way near the bottom of ingredients. It tastes good and is crunchy. It's about 3.29 per jar, about the same as other good peanut butters.

on April 8, 2021

I make sure I don't use bread and crackers, etc. I make a delicious salad dressing with Smuckers Natural crunchy peanut butter. I add tamari, a little lemon, grated ginger or powdered, a little stevia and water to make it less thick. I use it on a lettuce or veg salad. No sugar and no grain carbs. It is so good and healthy.

on May 27, 2021

Add a comment:


(required, never published)

© 2021