Is Carnation Breakfast Essentials Necessary?

My daughter's endocrinologist asked her to drink this because she gets a sick stomach from eating food in the morning before school. It does the trick for her, though I'd love to find something I could make without all those unnecessary ingredients. We also go with the low sugar one to keep her sugar in check.

Larell

I'm on a liquid diet due to digestive disease, and have been for years. I now blend whole foods for the most part, but for a very long time, I was formula dependent. I made my own after getting sick of the expense and chemical shitstorm that was the others. It's not very hard, really. No, it's not going to be scientifically accurate down to the gram, but I knew I was getting "enough" into me, and it kept me alive for years.

I used powdered milk, ovaltine chocolate malt (just because I like the flavor, and it has some added minerals to it), nutritional yeast, flax oil, commercial whey protein powder, and threw a multivitamin into the morning's dose. Sometimes a little chocolate syrup (Trader Joe's Midnight Moo is actual chocolate and sugar, not corn syrup and flavoring). I typically blended this with a frozen banana and milk, but sometimes just milk. I could handle the taste, it was all close to real food, and cost a fraction of the boxed stuff. I'd sometimes make it for my kids, too. No, it's not solid, but it's enough when it's all you can manage. I drank think 5-6x/day for years. I was never hungry, but then again, I'm NEVER hungry, so that doesn't matter much. I'm sure a human with a working gut would be hungry.

Estelle

Larell- what about a smoothie instead? My kids love them and it only takes about 5 minutes. I do admit washing the blender everyday stinks though!

I use - frozen banana+ another type of fruit, plain yogurt plus unsweetened vanilla almond milk. I also as a handful of spinach if I have it.

Andrea

I recently saw this commercial too and it made me want to scream. Oats takes minutes to make, no excuse.

Mandy@fatgirlgonehealthy

I tried another protein drink - special K I think - my oldest son tried one, proclaimed "yuk" - and the rest are in my fridge - I actually tried to use one in my coffee when we ran out of milk - "yuk." I too hate to think of throwing away $6 - but they are getting tossed.

Breakfast here is always a struggle - they just got up and aren't hungry / don't have time / eat lunch early at school. Today's mini success was handing the 13 year old a baggie of Oatmeal squares cereal as he walked out the door. "Can I eat these on the bus?" - Sure honey...

Maria

seems that this kind of product is mainly good for the producer's pocket but if it is sold, it means there is a demand for it, why? some of the commenters expressed what they are. some people find it hard to prepare thier own food, but if someone is prone to a little morning work, smoothies made of a concoction of a little water some fruits and some vegetables, that would be much, much better and healthier in any way.

Adi

Is vectora healthy energy bar?

Anninos Chouliotis

I make these for my grandkids in the morning...an egg scrambled in I microwave proof bowl sprayed with coconut spray, toss in some grated cheese( I use TJ's shredded Mexican blend but any grated cheese will do) Microwave for 1 minute. It's comes out nice and fluffy serve on a toasted whole grain English Muffin. They love it and can even eat it in the car on the way to school! If they have time, serve some fresh fruit on the side. Almond milk smoothies with fruit greens, yogurt whatever strikes you, are another favorite and you can buy paper cups with lids and straws for a to go drink!

Dale

I think some of you are missing the point. If your child (mine's 10) refuses to eat ANYTHING in the morning, this is better than nothing or a donut & vitamin. I buy the chocolate packets & make w/ my own organic milk--cheaper for 10 pkts, and the first ingredient listed (even before I add mine) is milk, not water or corn syrup. It contains the protein of 2 eggs (13g). I pack her healthy snacks & lunch from home. I'm not stupid enough to believe this is a health food, but it has been a good option for us. And I cannot imagine trying to serve my kid a smoothie of almond milk & spinach! If I could even get her to eat oatmeal, the low protein/high carb would not be a great choice for her. She stays pretty full for a few hours. It's a compromise I am willing to make, esp. since she eats more whole foods throughout the day.

DaisyCat68

I can understand someone wanting to use these type of drinks to supplement their nutritional needs if they are in a condition to where they can't eat or hold down solids,especially due to illness or surgery. However,I personally can't justify calling a drink a meal. It just doesn't seem like it would hold one over until the next meal. A thick smoothie would be a bit more filling if I wanted something that reminds me of a milkshake. I don't see how some people can wait until around noon to have their first meal. If I don't have a nice solid breakfsst with real food before 9am,I get cranky.

brandy

I love reading everyones input and ideas- they are actually very helpful. But, it is pretty easy to say certain things if you don't actually live it. My son has sensory Integration, and his main issue is FOOD--its awful- we have a horrible time with food- the easiest thing for most people is a chore for us. We make him a glass of ovaltine(with protein powder) for breakfast daily.....if he drinks all of this-- this makes me happy

Sherry

"Carnation instant breakfaaaast - you're gonna love it in an instant!" - sorry, that's been in my head since I saw this post in my inbox.

I haven't seen that commercial - the one you're referencing, SnackGirl - but I don't think I would ever choose to give this to my child. There is no "real" food in it. Even if like a previous commenter said that her doctor recommended it, I would try to find an alternative to make myself and only use this as a back-up. It amazes me how food companies are trying to pass off their products as healthy when they're full of sugar and sodium.

Janet

I don't usually comment, but I make a wonderful smoothie with banana, fruit(I use frozen berries), vanilla almond milk, rice plant protein powder, sometimes plain Greek yogurt. It is delicious! It keeps me full until lunch(I'm a teacher). Oatmeal never kept me full. I really look forward to it each morning. Breakfast doesn't have to be traditional.

Eileen Rupert

We don't use the specific product Snack Girl is talking about. But, we do keep the Carnation Instant Breakfast dry mix packets in our house. If we are running late or don't feel like eating, mixing a packet in milk gives us a drink that actually does taste good (chocolate milk) and the protein in it keeps us full all morning. It isn't perfect but sometimes it is good enough.

Diane

8 oz. Plain 0% fat Kefir (14g protein), a heavy tablespoon (or more) of Polaner's Sugar Free Strawberry Preserves, and a bunch of frozen NO SUGAR added strawberries - depending on how thick you like it! In a blender - most delicious smoothie ever. If you want even more protein, add a serving of your favorite chocolate or vanilla protein powder! Great breakfast for a college student on the run, and for my husband after the gym. I make a batch the night before, leave it in the refrigerator in the blender. Then in the morning I just add a bunch more frozen strawberries to thicken it up, and blend!

I think I originally found this recipe in the 17 Day Diet book!

Helene

I can't believe all the excuses I see for less than healthy breakfasts. Who is anyone kidding that sugar is better than corn syrup? They both are sugar, period. It is sugar that makes the child hungry later. Protein keeps them feeling full.

Why not oatmeal? It is a whole grain with 12% protein and 9% carbs. They have plain (no sugar)instant you know?

Ovaltine has sugar for the first ingredient! But, it has 10% of the daily requirement of vitamins that it lists.

http://www.shopwell.com/ovaltine-drink-mix-rich-chocolate/b…

Does anyone read a label?

And, be careful of using vitamin supplements and ask your doctor. It is now believed that if vitamins are not from whole foods they could be damaging.

Eggs are one perfect choice for children. You would not believe how many vitamins and minerals are in eggs. One egg is about 80 calories, throw in some cheese and you have of about 100 calories and should last your child until lunch.

"While it is true that egg yolk contains a high percentage of fat, it is unsaturated fat which is associated with "good" or HDL cholesterol. LDL is the type of cholesterol that lines blood vessels, whereas HDL cholesterol tends to remove LDL from artery walls and is known as "good" cholesterol. Consuming eggs rather than sources of animal protein which contain saturated fats might actually lower the chances of heart disease."

http://www.fitday.com/fitness-articles/nutrition/healthy-ea…

OR, buy some plain (no sugar) live culture yogurt or kefir and make a smoothie with a low glycemic sweetener. It takes seconds.

Better yet, make your own kefir. It can be low fat if you use low fat milk. I has over 3 times the beneficial cultures of yogurt and is cheap to make and EASY!

Kefir grains can be used over and over, just keep giving them fresh milk. The kefir grains are kept alive by "eating" the lactose and they actually multiply.

It is easy to build a supply and to keep culturing new batches. No special appliance or work is necessary. Get the wet "grains" not the freeze dried and you will save yourself a lot of work rehydrating them.

Here is a link regarding children's health and kefir:

http://nationalkefirassociation.com/Kefir/KidsCorner.aspx

Here is a smoothie recipe:

http://nationalkefirassociation.com/Recipes.aspx

Kefir has the protein, calcium, magnesium, and many other vitamins and minerals combined with healthy foods, I believe, gives a wider spectrum of usable nutrition.

If a child has a problem with food, there may be a medical issue. If not, then kefir may be the answer to good drinkable nutrition.

I_Fortuna

Yes, I read labels, I also struggle on a daily basis with my child who has severe eating issues, that is a challenge every single day- every single meal.

Again, its easy for people to judge and think how on earth are we not feeding our child certain things.

Unless you have walked in my shoes, you have no clue with what is going on.

We do the best with what situation we are given

Sherry

SnackGirl, you tricked me! Why isn't this photo black and white like your other "AVOID THIS JUNK" photos?? :) I saw the color photo and instantly thought, wow this article is going to tell us that this drink is an okay choice - how surprising! So I guess I'm glad to see that my initial thought (that the stuff is not nutritionally dense, shall we say) was correct, but it's always nice to be pleasantly surprised. Especially when it's a commercial foodstuffs manufacturer selling something that's actually healthful. Oh well.

While I think it's a stretch to say that eggs or oatmeal or homemade kefir are as easy and quick to make for a finicky kid on the way out the door in the morning, I will say that it seems far better to keep a bag of protein powder on hand to blend with milk, chocolate sauce, fruit, yogurt, or whatever. Ingredients matter. Corn syrup may be the same nutritionally as sugar, but it's also a red flag that the rest of the ingredients are probably also cheap, and that matters. Starting from plain milk or almond milk, adding a good quality scoop of protein and then some sweetness and flavoring seems the right approach, instead of starting with a sweetened powder that contains a lot of crap and who knows how much protein. I do this sometimes for myself or my daughter when we're in a rush, though I still get hungry in an hour or two - but I'm always hungry so it's not that big a deal. :)

One tip re: cleaning the blender - as soon as I pour the smoothie, I blast the empty blender pitcher with hot water from the sprayer, upside down over the sink. Then leave it on the drying rack or a towel upside down to drip dry. Gets it clean enough to use again the next day!

Christine

The old adage "If you can't pronounce the ingredients, don't eat it." holds true in this case. Here in Australia, fruit, vegies, healthy food options are tax free. Soda, candy, dog food, toilet cleaner do incur tax. Our tax is totaled at the bottom of the register receipt. My advice to Aussie folk is, if you pay minimal tax on your food items, it must be healthy.

Kay Stevens